1954: Started by the Beulah Home Demonstration Club as a means to raise money to build the Beulah Community Center.
1960: Lily the Felon’s Daughter, a new stage was built
1961 - On the Bridge at Midnight directed by Palmer Challela
1962: Deadwood Dick (Directed by Palmer Challela)
1963 - The Tavern directed by Challela
1964: Pure as the Driven Snow (Directed by Challela)
1965 - Lily the Felon's Daughter directed by Challela (repeated)
1966: Face on the Bar Room Floor (Directed by Challela, song leader Rod Myers)
1967: The Curse of an Aching Heart (Directed by Challela)
1968: The White Phantom (Directed by Challela, Asst. director Orville Myers)
1969: Under the Gaslight; and Pistol Pete (Directed by Elnora Lorje)
1970: |A Widow’s Weary Way and Our Gal Sal; (Directed by Elnora Lorje)
1972: Little Nell (Directed by Joan Thomson)
1973: Dirty Work at the Crossroads, the stage was in the Otterstein yard
1974: No Mother to Guide Her (Directed by Orville Myers) at GayWay
1975: On the Bridge at Midnight (Directed by Orville Myers)
1976: Blazing Guns at Roaring Gulch (Produced by Tryna Fredregill and directed by Elnora Lorje, in conjunction with Pioneer Drama Services)
Beulah Valley Arts Council takes on sponsorship of Beulah Melodrama
1983: The Shagwood Secret (Directed by Orville Myers), labeled a comeback
1984: Curse of an Aching Heart (Directed by Orville Myers)
1986: Little Nell the Orphan Girl (Directed by Orville Myers and asst. director Kristy Kreusch).
1987: Pure as the Driven Snow (Directed by Orville Myers)
1988: Egad the Woman in White, sponsored by BVAC (Directed by Orville Myers)
1989: Caught in the Villain’s Web (Directed by Orville Myers)
1993: How the West Was Fun (Directed by Orville Myers)
1996: The Picture That Was Turned to the Wall (Directed by Orville Myers)
2001: James Amos wrote and directed a small melodrama that was performed at the Arts Show in the Mtn. Park (Southern Colorado Theater Company/SCTC)
2002: Dastardly Deeds in Deadwood (written and directed by James Amos) SCTC
2003: Ranger’s Danger (directed by Geoffrey Simmons) SCTC
2004: Stop the Presses, SCTC
2005: No, No, A Thousand Times No (Directed by Leta Langdon and Amy Hardwick) SCTC
2006: “B” Mine Forever (directed by Leta Langdon) Southern Colorado Theater Company changed their name to Steel City Theater Company (SCTC).
2007: Someone Save My Baby, Ruth (directed by Leta Langdon) SCTC
2008: The Villain Wore a Dirty Shirt (directed by Eli Cranson & Leta Langdon) SCTC
2009: Dr. Molar the Devious Dentist (directed by Leta Langdon) Hell and High Water Theatrical Association (HHWTA)
2010: Showdown at Sundown (directed by Leta Langdon) HHWTA
2011: Blazing Guns at Roaring Gulch (10 year anniversary) (directed by Bill Wright. Assistant Director Dawn Thompson) HHWTA
2013: The Baron’s Revenge (directed by Dawn Thompson & Josh Cordova) HHWTA
2014: Vaudeville Galore (directed by Leta Langdon) HHWTA
2018: If Not Mace’s Hole, Then Who’s Hole Is It? Written by John Russell, directed by Lori Lara
2019: Pole-Er Opposites, written by Natalie Anderson, directed by Lori Lara
2021: Muldoon Caper, written by Renee Budde directed by Lori Lara
2022: Licensed to Steal, written by John Russell, directed by Lori Lara